9 Valentine’s Day Dinners for Two for When You’d Rather Stay In

If you’re not feeling the crowds, the rush, and the wait times for eating out on Valentine’s Day, then a dinner for 2 at home is perfect.

You can set the pace, get fixed up without worrying about reservations, eat exactly what you want, pick the playlist, and not worry about others overhearing your conversation.

It really is a good solution and if you’re looking for menu options that are easy and try-worthy, then these Valentine’s Day dinner for two ideas are a great place to start. You’ll both be able to enjoy an amazing Valentine’s menu, no reservation needed.

1. Date Night Rigatoni

I always trust Pinch of Yum’s recipes, so I’m gonna recommend her date night rigatoni. It looks incredibly creamy and savory, and the perfect romantic dinner for when you’re staying in on Valentine’s Day.

And if you’re both craving something with garlic, wine, and parmesan (because who isn’t) then this is a great option for your Valentine’s Day menu.

GET THE RECIPE

2. Marry Me Chicken

I’m sorry, but this chicken recipe really does look good. It looks ridiculously creamy, tangy, and worth the effort. And while I haven’t had this specific recipe, I have had marry me chicken before and really liked it. Just pair it with some nice pasta and you’re all set for the evening.

GET THE RECIPE

3. Cheesy Lasagna Soup

If you want a good soup recipe for your menu, then I think this lasagna soup is probably a good idea. You get some amazing flavors, cheesy goodness, and it looks very satisfying.

Also, there’s just something that feels more romantic (and extra) about serving a lasagna soup for your Valentine’s day dinner.

GET THE RECIPE

4. Creamy Sage Chicken

This looks like an amazing Valentine’s date night dinner that you could pair with your favorite pasta! Also, it’s just 5 minutes of prep which means you have more time to work on other parts of your Valentine’s dinner for 2.

GET THE RECIPE

5. Crockpot Cranberry Pork Tenderloin

If you want something that cooks throughout the day so that there’s less on your mind, then this very tasty-looking dinner is gonna be your answer. With zesty, sweet, and savory flavors, it looks and sounds like the perfect recipe to pair with rice for your Valentine’s Day at home.

GET THE RECIPE

6. Cheesecake Factory Chicken Piccata

Whether you’re a Cheesecake Factory lover or not, this chicken piccata recipe looks ridiculously good! It’s done in just 30 minutes and perfect if the both of you love Italian-inspired dishes. Just pair it with your favorite type of pasta and you’ll have a romantic (and tasty) Valentine’s dinner for two.

GET THE RECIPE

7. Oven Cooked Steak

If you’re craving steak, then I’d say give this how-to on oven cooking your steak a try. It’s really fast, easy, and looks really good!

Also, this might just be a great option if the both of you like the idea of cooking dinner together and making it a team effort.

GET THE RECIPE

8. Chicken Marsala

I feel like creamy savory chicken dishes like this will always be a great idea for a romantic night in. Also, I’d suggest pairing it with some mashed potatoes, but that’s just me.

GET THE RECIPE

9. One Pot Pasta With Ricotta and Lemon

If you want a one-pot hassle-free dinner that looks like it’s restaurant quality, then I’d definitely try this recipe. The ingredients all sound so good. So for instance, you’re getting things like ricotta, parmesan, lemon zest, and cream.

Also, if you wanna take it a step further, then I’d recommend making a simple 2-ingredient pasta like strozzapreti. It requires no pasta machine and is super satisfying. Also, I feel like anything made from scratch is a nice way to celebrate Valentine’s Day.

Side Note: Here’s the strozzapreti recipe I personally tried.

GET THE RECIPE

---